Caution: Plot Holes Ahead

I was thinking about a story where Elle discovers true pleasure with somebody else than Sylar (not a typical fanfic I think). She tries to threat Mohinder and Matthew, but receives a bucketful of water, and the men's revenge is... Something finally sweet, not dark. Not dark enough perhaps? I am not really tempted by angst and non-con these days. But follow your idea, I trust your talent.
P.S: Please don't take care of my possible grammatical mistakes.